The purpose of this study was to investigate whether patients with low preoperative Diffusion-weighted Imaging Alberta Stroke Program Early Computed Tomography Score (DWI-ASPECTS) could benefit from mechanical thrombectomy for acute anterior circulation occlusion. This was a retrospective, non-blinded, cohort study. From September 2012 to August 2016, 83 consecutive patients of acute anterior circulation occlusion were treated with thrombectomy using second-generation devices or medical management. The DWI-ASPECTS was scored after the first MRI. Patient characteristics and clinical outcomes were compared between the treatment groups. Significant dependence was defined as a modified Rankin scale score ≥3 at 90 days. As a result, 33 patients underwent mechanical thrombectomy and 50 received medical management. In the mechanical thrombectomy group, the variable of lower DWI-ASPECTS (5, 4–6 vs. 8, 7–8, P < 0.001), especially ≤6, was significantly associated with poor prognosis. However, compared with patients of DWI-ASPECTS ≤ 6 who received medical management, there were significantly fewer patients with poor outcomes in thrombectomy (dependent in 11 of 15 vs. 23 of 23, respectively; P = 0.019). Although patients with lower pretreatment DWI-ASPECTS could benefit less from thrombectomy, their outcomes were still better than medical management. Therefore, mechanical thrombectomy could be considered in some patients with low pretreatment DWI-ASPECTS.